Challenges in Implementation of Agenda 2022

jatin
By jatin June 12, 2019 12:00

Download PDF


Article highlight the challenges in the implementation of NITI Aayog agenda 2022 and suggests some measures.

Important Analysis

Agriculture:

  • The document suggests converting farmers into “agripreneurs” by expanding the e-National Agriculture Markets and replacing the existing Agricultural Produce Marketing Committee Act.
  • A model Bill proposed in 2017 has not made much headway possibly because it extinguishes middlemen and commission agents.
    • The state bureaucracy’s uninspiring performance in replacing water-intensive crops, containing wasteful irrigation practices and the alarming depletion of groundwater does not bode well for effecting radical change.

Sanitation:

  • Agenda 2022 gives primacy to gargantuan problems such as landfills, plastic waste and sustainable revenue generation from municipal waste.It seeks to subsume these neglected areas under the Swachh Bharat Mission.
    • But unless the municipal commissioners compel waste segregation and deter non-compliance with fines and penalties available under the solid waste, plastic and water pollution rules, cleanliness cannot come.
    • Municipal commissioners and district magistrates rarely act. Unless municipal offences are fined heavily on-the-spot like traffic violations, the goals cannot be realised.

Power:

  • Agenda 2022 seeks to rationalise power tariff to promote the use of renewable energy.
    • But without privatising the DISCOMs, good intentions will not change the ethos underlying distribution. To reap the benefits of renewable energy fully, only privatising the DISCOMs can rationalise power purchase and tariff.
    • No chief minister is however willing to privatise power distribution and bureaucracy by itself cannot usher in privatisation. Delhi remains the solitary exception.

Read Also: Cabinet Committees

Employment:

  • The codification of labour laws and expanding apprenticeships will boost employment but unless industry has the flexibility to make a transition from micro-to-small to medium-to-large manufacturing, apprentices will have few places to learn on the job.
    • The flexibility to reduce the workforce within the law must be ensured and the backlash met firmly. This will present the biggest challenge for bureaucracy.

Procurement:

  • Modernising public procurement systems to international competitive bidding (ICB) standards is another important reform.
    • Unless there is willingness to outsource this to professional bodies, ICB will stay on paper. The move will meet with stiff resistance from state politicians, contractors and lobbies. No bureaucracy can pursue this proposal without solid political backing

Governance:

  • India’s first deputy Prime Minister, Vallabhai Patel, wanted IAS officers to be men of integrity and capable of “brashness” possibly meaning bold, audacious and self-assertive. But today brashness is unacceptable to bosses within the political executive and the bureaucracy.
    • IAS remains indispensable primarily because the officers provide an interface with the political executive and handle complex federal issues, Centre-State relations and municipal and panchayat governance functions.
    • They coordinate and interact meaningfully through a nationwide network which remains matchless. No chief minister can run his government without them.

Suggestions

  • First, subdivide the 41 identified goals into those which require the approval of Parliament or state legislatures. Set up empowered councils headed by a central minister with state ministers as members to reach consensus within six months on the lines of the VAT and GST councils. The central and state bureaucracies function best under this edifice.
  • Second, in areas which fall in the state domain, create one working model of each of the following in a single State, city or district to emulate.
    • Establishing a Unified Metropolitan Transport Authority in a million-plus cities
    • Establishing public health cadres, introducing user charges for garbage collection and toilet maintenance
    • Using treated wastewater for non-potable purposes
  • Third If Agenda 2022 is to become a reality both at the Centre and in the states, there should be sizeable induction of professionals but only by following rigorous and transparent processes for selection.

Source

Read More Articles:

The 9-Point Agenda

India – South Africa Relations

jatin
By jatin June 12, 2019 12:00